Bissell and Rug Doctor are both well-known brands in carpet cleaning. Both of these carpet cleaners provide top performance. Both models are powerful, commercial-grade carpet cleaners. They are designed to deal with tough stains, high-traffic dirt, and pet messes.
Both carpet cleaners are loved by users for their solid build quality, powerful suction, and commercial-grade cleaning performance. In this comparison, we’ll break down everything from cleaning power to ease of use so you can decide which one is truly worth your investment.
Comparison Table
| Feature | Bissell Big Green | Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3 |
|---|---|---|
| Cleaning Path Width | 10.5 inches | 10.8 inches |
| Tank Capacity | 1.75 gallons (clean) / 1.75 gallons (dirty) | 3.9 gallons (combined capacity) |
| Power Cord Length | 25 feet | 28 feet |
| Hose Length | 9 feet | 7.7 feet |
| Weight | 40.6 lbs (without water) | 39 lbs (without water) |
| Warranty | 5-year limited warranty | 5-year limited warranty (via Rug Doctor) |
| Price | ~$470–$500 USD | ~$430–$470 USD |
Bissell Big Green
The Bissell Big Green is one of the most popular carpet cleaners. It’s known for its solid build quality, strong suction, and cleaning performance. This carpet cleaner is designed to handle large areas. The build quality of this carpet cleaner is strong enough for use in a rental fleet.
The Bissell Big Green can hold up to 1.7 gallons of clean water. It also uses the water efficiently. Unlike the Rug Doctor X3, the Bissell Big Green can be used both in backward pull and forward push, making it more efficient and easier to use.
Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3
The Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3 is another popular professional-grade carpet cleaner. Just like the Bissell Big Green, it’s designed to handle tough stains, pet odor, and remove embedded dirt. The Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3 uses a powerful jet to inject cleaning solution deep in carpets. After injecting solution, it uses a vibrating brush to scrub carpets. After that, it uses its strong suction power to remove dirt, grime, and odors.
You can also purchase an upholstery tool to clean your sofas, chairs, and other furniture in your home. This tool provides you endless versatility.
Performance Comparison
We at Vacuumadvice have conducted multiple tests to find the winner. We also analyzed real user feedback to provide you a clearer, more complete comparison.
Cleaning Power
We tested both carpet cleaners to see which one handles stains and pet messes better. We tested both models on the same carpet. We used Bissell Big Green to clean one half of the carpet while the Rug doctor was used to clean the other half. While testing, we followed the manufacturer’s recommended cleaning procedures and also used their cleaning solutions.
The result? The Bissell Big Green won with a little margin. However, both carpet cleaners did an exceptional job; the Rug Doctor was one step behind Bissell. The Bissell was able to completely remove stains in 3 passes, while the Rug Doctor did the same job in 4 passes.
Drying Time
The Bissell is a winner in drying time too. We noticed the area cleaned by Bissell started drying a little faster than the one cleaned by the Rug Doctor. One user on amazon highlighted that the Big Green extracted significantly more water, resulting in quicker drying times.
On the other hand, the Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3 is reported to leave carpets wetter. It requires more time compared to the Bissell.
User-Friendliness
In our user-friendliness, the Bissell Big Green scores high. The feature we liked the most is that Bissell can clean in both directions (forward and backward). It makes the whole cleaning process faster since you don’t need to reposition it after every pass.
In summary, while both machines offer professional-grade cleaning performances, the Bissell Big Green stands out in several key areas, including deep-cleaning efficiency, faster drying times, user-friendly design, and included accessories. The Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3 is also effective but requires additional investments and considerations to match the convenience offered by the Bissell Big Green.